What if the perfect picture was edited?

05 December 2018   •  
Written by Lou Tsatsas
What if the perfect picture was edited?

Bizarre or trending subjects? Catch a break with our curiosity of the week. The Migrant Mother is one of the most famous pictures by photographer Dorothea Lange. But did you know that it was edited back in 1939?

In 1936, the Great Depression carried on, in the United States, following the market crash of 1929. President Franklin Roosevelt crafted a series of programmes called New Deal, hoping to help the rural and poor communities. One of the bills crafted supervised the creation of the Resettlement Administration (RA) – an agency relocating those populations.

The same year, photographer Dorothea Lange agreed to capture, for the RA, the daily lives of those poor communities and migrants, to highlight the blatant inequalities of the American society. Among the pictures taken in the field, the migrant mother stood out.

A surprising detail

Looking away, a worried wrinkle on her face, the woman symbolised the hopelessness of American migrants. A photographic masterpiece. Yet, in her new book called Dorothea Lange: Migrant Mother, Sarah Meister, curator of the MoMA, revealed a surprising detail: the original photo has been edited. On the right of the image, the mother’s left thumb was erased. While the curator’s revelation was presented as a simple anecdote, the edit, dating back to 1939, had infuriated the director of the Resettlement Administration. To him, retouching the image compromised its authenticity.

“Dorothea Lange considered that the thumb was such a big defect that she has no hesitation removing it from the pictures”, Sarah Meister told the Times. An aesthetic edit, which did not make the migrant’s gaze any less moving. Indeed, the curator only shared the information in order to help the most curious ones of us recognize whether a copy would be older than 1939. An edit that went unnoticed, and make us wander: are all historical images authentic?

© Dorothea Lange, courtesy library of congress© Dorothea Lange, courtesy library of congress

© Dorothea Lange, courtesy library of congress

© Dorothea Lange, courtesy library of congress

Source : The New York Times

Explore
France 98, Luke Skywalker and street photography: Laurent le Crabe's Chinese portrait
France 98, Luke Skywalker and street photography: Laurent le Crabe’s Chinese portrait
"As the son of a printer, I was immersed from an early age in a culture of images and colour", says Laurent le Crabe, who, as he grew up...
28 July 2021   •  
Written by Anaïs Viand
Macron, Brexit and family albums: Ed Alcock's Chinese portrait
Macron, Brexit and family albums: Ed Alcock’s Chinese portrait
Portrait photographer for many news publications – Le Monde, El País, the New York Times – documentary photographer and member of the...
22 July 2021   •  
Written by Lou Tsatsas
"While everyone knows how to draw a penis and testicles, a vulva or a clitoris is a problem"
“While everyone knows how to draw a penis and testicles, a vulva or a clitoris is a problem”
With Récupérer Nos Corps (Getting our bodies back, ed.), a project combining written testimonies and photographs, non-binary artist La...
14 July 2021   •  
Written by Lou Tsatsas
Belgium, pasta taster, and dangerous nipples: Charlotte Abramow's Chinese portrait
Belgium, pasta taster, and dangerous nipples: Charlotte Abramow’s Chinese portrait
She is Belgian, but lives in France. She has been challenging the clichés associated with female beauty and celebrating bodies in her...
11 July 2021   •  
Written by Anaïs Viand
Our latest articles
View all articles
Readers picks #355
Readers picks #355
Alexander Kaller and Stephen Sillifant, our readers picks #355, both escape the frenzy of our world to produce peaceful images – a...
30 August 2021   •  
Written by Fisheye Magazine
British seaside, round animals and Céline Sciamma: Max Miechowski's Chinese portrait
British seaside, round animals and Céline Sciamma: Max Miechowski’s Chinese portrait
Trained as a musician, British artist Max Miechowski turned to photography after a long trip to Southeast Asia. Portraits...
25 August 2021   •  
Written by Lou Tsatsas
Instagram selection #312
Instagram selection #312
Through portraits or landscapes, the artists of our Instagram selection #312 never stop experimenting. All of them seek new textures and...
24 August 2021   •  
Written by Joachim Delestrade
The labourer who turned mud into silver
The labourer who turned mud into silver
With Zilverbeek (Silver creek), Lucas Leffler explores the myth of a worker who made his wealth from the mud that lined the bottom of a...
23 August 2021   •  
Written by Finley Cutts